A Fish Potty Trained My Child

Feb 20th 2010

Meet Diego.  He single-handedly (or is that single Fin-dedly?) potty trained my child.

Okay, lemme back up a minute.  My older son is 3 and a half, and has flatly refused to use the potty for the last 2 years.  We’ve tried everything (and I really mean everything) but the boy could not be convinced.  He preferred wearing diapers all day and night, and would never accept any motivation (oh hell, let’s just call it what it is: bribes) to go on the potty instead.

About a month ago I decided that I should buy him a fish.  He loves fish, and I thought it could be just the thing to bribe him with.  M&Ms and lollipops stopped working over a year ago.  So I put up a sticker chart on the bathroom wall  and told him that every time he went poop in the potty, he could have a sticker.  After three weeks of stickers, he could pick out a fish.  That was our deal.

Yeah.  That shit didn’t work either.  I think he only went poop in the potty about 1/4 of the last 21 days.  BUT, for some unexplainable reason, I still really wanted to buy him a fish.  So yesterday we went to the store, and after he picked out exactly the fish he wanted, AND named him, I told him we’d have to go somewhere and talk about what having a fish would mean.

So I took him by the boys’ clothes department and told him that if he started wearing underwear instead of Pull-ups or diapers, and started using the potty like a big kid, then he could buy his fish – because only big kids can take care of fish, right JonasRight, Mom. This all seemed to make sense to him, so we bought him some underwear, then bought him the fish – along with a “toy” for the fish, and some food, and a pretty little one gallon tank.

The child was over-the-moon excited.  All he wanted to do was go home and help me put Diego in his new home.  And right after we got Diego settled in, I went to nurse Julesy down for his nap.  A few minutes into it, just as Julesy is dosing off, I hear Jonas grunting from the next room.  I say

“Jonas?  What are you doing?”

And to my heart’s delight he yells back,

“I’m going poop and pee in the potty, Mommy!”

And so he was.  It’s been 24 hours now, and the child has not had a single accident.  Not even during the night.  Some times we ask him to go, and other times he just yells to no one,

“Oh!  I gotta go pee/poop!”

and runs himself into the bathroom to put the pee or poop right where it belongs.

Now, I cannot say for sure that he is 100% potty-trained from now until forever (that’s a lot of pressure to put on poor little Diego), but this 24 hours has most certainly been the most success we have ever seen with it.

Even if he regresses now, this 24 hours of diaper-free Jonas is enough of a high to last me another 6 months, if that’s what it takes.  So thank you little fishy – you have already paid for yourself in unused Pull-Ups.

__________________________________________

UPDATE! Two weeks later, I’m happy to say that Jonas has remained 100% diaper-free.  The kid even stands up to pee now, and he does potty time all by himself without even being asked.  He even puts the toilet seat back down when he’s done!  What a man!

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Earth Mama Angel Baby


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

for my daughter at 3 it was a hermit crab! Same exact situation!

Hello everyone, I hope this message finds you well.

I need some help. The school my son attends requires that he be fully potty trained so I got him potty trained since May 2010. Once school began, he was scared and cried a lot for the first 3 weeks and peed on himself. The school changed him at first and then one day when they ran out of changes of clothes, purchased pull-ups and requested that I send him in pull-ups going forward. I did and now my son does not let me know when he needs to go even though I put underwear on him as soon as he gets home. In essence, he is using the pull-ups as diapers and I feel that we totally went backwards and I'm not sure what to do. He is not escorted to the bathroom, he is placed at the door and expected to use the toilet. To start, my son feels compelled to get totally naked from the waste down in order to use the bathroom, and uses the toilet sitting down. I really want to change something but am not sure where to start.
Any suggestions?

UPDATE! Two weeks later, I’m happy to say that Jonas has remained 100% diaper-free. The kid even stands up to pee now, and he does potty time all by himself without even being asked. He even puts the toilet seat back down when he’s done! What a man!

Haha sorry for that little dissertation, the best of luck to you =). Being a future psychology major, I would love to learn more about your bold plans. (i'll comment in the proper place next time sorry)

I'm a male and I admit i haven't explored the content of your website and i'm commenting here because this is the only area I can find to voice my opinions. So i'm watching a special about your amazing family on some health channel and i'm seeing a few issues with what you are doing. I'm curious as to how your children are being prepared for the challenges they will face our dark and cold world. You seem to be favoring a femine undertone to your parenting. This is makes sense seeing as they are undoubtedly geting male symbols placed on them by the wider world. Your tactics will ensure a balanced gender view on the part of your child. However with the positives of compassion, understanding and cooperation, you may also pass on the qualities that are unfairly and unfortunately attached to the "normal" feminine gender view. You may send your child the message that it is correct to be docile and subservient. Humbleness and love are admirable but the above qualities will not keep your children from becomeing the powerful harbingers of a gender nuetral society. In short, I hope that your children take in every good feminine and masculine quality and none of the negative ones.

I keep telling my 3 1/2 year old I will buy her a scooter when she poops on the potty (she's been peeing on the potty for over a year now for goodness sake). Now I am tempted to just go ahead and buy her the darn scooter!

Congrats! It's a long haul, isn't it? Potty training has been a bit of a nightmare for my youngest. He turned four in January and that was when he finally decided to do it. Like you, we'd tried everything - stickers, charts, bribes. And the thing that finally worked was the "Easy Button" from Staples. When he goes, he gets to press it (and then have a bit of time on Club Penguin). Yeah for real underwear! And goodbye to diapers! Woo hoo!
.-= Jacquie @ Wild Mother Arts´s last blog ..I am powerful, pregnant and proud! =-.

That is awesome Diego worked! Have you thought about looking into Elimination Communication with the next baby? I only have one so I do have more time to watch for cues with my son, but we started at 3 months and it has worked great for us. It is kind of like breastfeeding in reverse. The same way your new baby signals they are hungry with non verbal cues, they also give cues they need to pee or poo, but most parents don't look for them and babies are trained to go in the diaper. It doesn't work for every one and I was skeptical at first, but my 7.5 mo regularly poops on the potty and has for 2 months and he stays dry most if not all night now. Just an idea :) I can give you links if you want to read more :)

Love this story and hope that Diego's magic holds for you! For us potty-training has always involved going straight to underwear (ok, that was daycare's idea, but it worked!) except at night. Nights weren't a real problem but thanks to a strong desire to not re-start the night waking for any reason, I just left them in pullups until there were like three straight months of dry nights and then let them wear their underwear to bed.
.-= Laurie´s last blog ..WAHM Wednesday: Working Alone =-.

Gina,
I'm so glad it worked. I've heard from friends that boys are tougher than girls. J trained herself (totally undies for 3 months) but then changed her mind for 6 months back in diapers. But I felt lucky that it didn't take longer. Then with dd #2 we started EC at birth- a much different experience.

What a great idea with the fish and I'm with you that a good 24 hours makes whatever happens next manageable.
WTG Jonas!
.-= Karen´s last blog ..Origins of Protocol-Centered Delivery (a cynical view) =-.

woo-hoo! Way to go Jonas!

What a great idea. Mason is 3, and he will NOT use the potty. I have tried bribes too, but they NEVER worked for him. Candy? Nope. A new toy? Nope. NOTHING!

Mason loves fish... hmmmmm.... I think we may try this too. If this doesn't work though, I am convinced he will be is diapers forever.

Yay!!! I think some kids just have to own the decision. It has to be their choice, not yours. Maybe your words allowed him to realize that he was deciding to potty train. I bet he will not go back now. My daughter went from 100% poop in diaper to 100% poop in potty. She decided, on her own terms, and she never went back.

Bribes didn't work for any of my kids. They learned when they learned and I don't think I had anything to do with it. I did flip out big time on a pediatrician who tugged at my eldest's diaper (at 2+ years old) and said, "What's this about? You're too big for diapers!" Once my son was out of earshot I went totally batshit on the man for trying humiliation as a tactic.

IMHO, the coolest potty training tool is those biodegradable targets you drop in for them to shoot pee at. None of my kids were at all interested, but I found them an interesting challenge. ;)

Really writing with a heads-up about the fish. Could just be me and my bad fish karma but they die pretty quickly. Your Diego made me think of DS2's Dora who he thinks was one fish but was actually like four different fish because I kept replacing her when she died. The funeral when I gave up and let him know one died was traumatic. Years later when we moved, he wept because he was leaving Dora behind (Dora #4 was buried in the backyard unlike the early Doras who were flushed).
.-= Jake Aryeh Marcus´s last blog ..Damaged By Accidentally Breastfeeding Someone Else’s Baby? Seriously?? =-.

I hear you on the potty training Gina. My oldest didn't potty train until she was 3 and 10 months! I needed special permission to enroll her in pre-school even! One day I just refused to put a diaper on her. We'd just run out and I was done buying more. She had a few accidents the first two days but once she got the idea that I was serious she stopped and We've been accident free in the day AND night ever since.
.-= Melodie´s last blog ..How and Why I Became Vegetarian =-.

That's awesome! Sometimes it just takes the right motivation. It took me FOREVER with DS1 (mostly due to the fact that I was working and his caregivers would just keep him in pullups the whole time I was gone).

Finally it was just as if something clicked in his head and no more "accidents".

I am curious how DS2 will be when he decides to use the potty.
.-= Sarah @ OneStarryNight´s last blog ..Pumpkin Chili =-.

I'm all for bribing children.

Only I call it "making contracts" because that sounds more like I'm teaching them the sort of skills that rich and successful people have and less like I'm tricking them into doing the things I want them to do.

Either way it totally works.
.-= Betsy´s last blog ..Birth Performance Anxiety, or, unassisted in a yurt with Enya in an owl-sanctuary =-.

Ahhh, congrads! My 3 year old is still quite selective. First morning poo ONLY and thats it (the kid craps like 5 times a day). MaybeI shoudl try bribing Mason with fish...hhmmmm
.-= Betty B´s last blog ..composting toilets/outdoor showers, and bobcats, oh mY! =-.

You have just given me hope. My son is 3.5 and while he uses the potty to pee at daycare, he totally refuses to use the potty anywhere else. I wonder if I could get away with a plant instead of a fish, though...

@RockStarMel - I totally agree. This wouldn't have worked if he didn't want it to. He must finally just be ready - or at least ready to start thinking about staying ready.

For us it was a combination of 2 things that finally put us over the edge... We went on a group camping trip on which a few of the already 3 and 4 year old boys asked Levi why he still needed a "diaper" and showed him how to properly water the bushes.

Then, when we got home, I finally broke down and did the potty chart thing. Small star stickers for pee, and big glittery stickers for poop. And when we got to the end of the chart, he got... SPIDER MAN UNDEROOS. And what did I do? I purchased the reward in advance, placed it on top of the hutch on my desk where he could see but not reach/open them, and occasionally before or after potty time, he'd ask to look at them and I'd oblige -- you know, to keep him "motivated."

But I still ultimately believe no matter what the bribe, they won't do it until they're good and (emotionally AND physically) ready.

Yay for Diego and Jonas!
I hope it works out!
.-= Danielle´s last blog ..“Elective Cesareans are too risky!” – WHO =-.

Yay Jonas!

It took me going on a child free weekend to London for Ewan to potty train at the ripe old age of 4 and 1/4.

Wow, that's awesome! I hope it keeps working. What a great strategy!
.-= Crunchy Nurse´s last blog ..Early Concerns to Autism Spectrum Diagnosis, The Toddler Years =-.