And Maybe I Could Be a Better Hostess…

May 28th 2010

On the heels of my post the other day about blog commenting etiquette, the sequel to that post should really be me pointing out the shortcomings in my blog management.

A year or two ago, when I would get a comment, I would reply to it.  I replied to just about every one of them.  I was so thrilled to have someone on my blog, interacting with me, complimenting me, or even questioning me.  Back in those days, I felt like a post had blown up when there were 15 comments on it, and I was grateful for every person who took the time to hit “Submit.”

But things have changed since then.  Don’t get me wrong, I’m still grateful for the commentors, and I’m still thrilled that people take the time to hit “Submit.”  The quality of my commentors, I feel, has become so much richer in the last 12 months.  The quantity of them has also multiplied greatly.

But things have changed for me personally in that time.  During the last year I spent at my corporate job, I had a lot of “free” time on my hands.  I can say this now that I don’t work there anymore, but I spent a WHOLE LOT of company time updating my blog and replying to commentors.  I was also pumping breastmilk 3 times a day back then, and for the hours a day I spent in the Mother’s Room, I was always pumping hands-free so I could type away.  If I wasn’t doing my homework in the Mother’s Room, I was most certainly plugging away on TheFeministBreeder.com.  For a solid 8 hours, 5 days a week, I worked free of almost all interruptions aside from the occasional co-worker drive-by, or the meetings I couldn’t get out of attending.  I had mentally checked out of that place, and wouldn’t allow the stress of a totally meaningless job invade my mind anymore.  Looking back, I’m surprised I made it there as long as I did.

But the combination of being home with two little kids, and the increase in blog traffic, contributed to the slow deterioration of my interaction with my commentors.  I no longer have the time to respond to everyone, and I’m sure that annoys people.

I know that I have personally quit following blogs when the author never takes the time to respond to me.  It may seem juvenile, but if she never responds, I wonder if she hates me and wishes I’d stop leaving her comments. And I really hope that none of my tribe ever feels that way.

Most of the time, I’m reading my blog comments on my iPhone while the children are running around the house.  The comments always make me chuckle, or warm my heart, or make me feel connected to someone.  So many times, I’ll think “That was the most awesome comment ever!” but rarely do I come back to tell the commentor that.  I don’t mean to be an asshole – I swear. Life just takes over, I get distracted, and then I forget.  Or, I take for granted that that person already knows what a great comment it was, and don’t think it needs a response.

But if I were the commentor, it would bum me out.  I know how it feels to try to engage someone and not have them respond.  So, in the future, I’m going to consider comment management part and parcel of having this blog.  I need to stay on top of it, so that’s what I’ll do.  I can’t promise that I’ll be able to respond to everyone, but I’ll do my best.

How do you feel about getting a response from your blog hostess?  Does it annoy you when she doesn’t reciprocate, or do you not care one way or the other?

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Earth Mama Angel Baby


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I have also been wrestling with this. Depending on the post I get a few or a lot of comments. I read them all on my iPhone (except I am having an issue with emailed comments as of late) but then forget to reply or don't get the time. I do the same with emails. Part is due to my toddler climbing the walls, the other is due to starting a new job.

I never really check back to see if an author commented back on my comment but I know some people do. Whenever it is a really great comment I do make it a point to reply.
.-= Kim´s last blog ..Bum Essentials Bumbino Giveaway (6/14) =-.

I love getting replies to my comments, but the only time I would be annoyed about not getting a reply would be if I was disagreeing with something the author had said or telling him/her that something s/he had said had annoyed me. Even then, I probably wouldn't be annoyed *at the author*, just annoyed in the impersonal sort of way you're annoyed when you just miss a green light, if you see what I mean. It would be downright hypocritical of me to be annoyed, because I am terrible about replying to comments myself. When an author doesn't reply, I just assume that they didn't have time and/or didn't have anything to say (I mean, some comments don't even really require an answer - I think it a bit pointless for someone to feel they have to say 'Thank you for your words' all the time.)

Anyway, cut yourself some slack! You're a busy lady and already do a great job updating this. If you haven't got time to reply to comments then you haven't got time. We're all in the same boat. ;-)
.-= Dr Sarah´s last blog ..And now the end is near =-.

TFB- that's a tough one. I commend you for writing a post about this, first of all. I think most people understand that you have 2 little ones, school, etc, so it's no biggie that you don't reply to all of them. But, I get what you're saying. I think it's like this: If you go someone's open play group and you try to talk the hostess mom a couple of times, she doesn't hear you or is too busy, it's okay. But, after the third time if you get no response, I think most people would find a new play group. Ya know?
Maybe not the best analogy, I know. I mean, does Heather Armstrong reply to all her commenters? Good god, no! So, when you make it BIG time like her, we don't expect any replies ;)
.-= Andrea Owen´s last blog ..What do you want to BE when you grow up? =-.

If indeed comment on a blog like this - or a post with say over 10 comments, I don't expect a reply. I would not unfollow a blog simply because the writer does not interact with me.
I do not reply to every single comment either, because it is simply impossible.
However, if I comment regularly on a blog that doesnot have that many commenters, I do resent it a little to get no reply and I start wondering why this blogger never replies in general or to me as a person.
I also have a lot of unpopularity feelings left over from my school days, so...
.-= mamapoekie´s last blog ..Bebe Choco And The Spoiled Child =-.

I am in the over-thankful stage of blogging. I love getting comments and always respond. I would love to have so many that I am not able to respond to them all. My opinion about replying is that you need to do it right away. Send the reply as soon as you read the comment. You could plan to reply to 5 comments a day or something managable. Switching it up so everyone gets a reply within a month.
.-= Kristin Glasbergen´s last blog ..Size Does Matter =-.

"It may seem juvenile, but if she never responds, I wonder if she hates me and wishes I’d stop leaving her comments." This. But only when I leave either a question or I comment *a lot* and never get a reply.

I think when you have a big blog (like yours or Baby Rabies in the mom community or like Gala Darling in the style community), it really means a LOT to your followers when you visit their site at all. I have had a couple starstruck moments in my years of blogging when a popular blogger leaves me so much as a "Thanks for the comment" on my site.

Mostly though, I think no comment is better than most "Nice blog/post" comments, especially when the days of commenting other blogs just to bring yourself traffic are (I think) over.
.-= Janine´s last blog ..Zebra Baby Romper, Betseyville & more on ideeli Today =-.

In an expression of irony, I will not post a response to all the awesome responses above :) How's that for hypocrisy?! I'm getting the sense that this is one of those things I spent time stressing about, which didn't need to be stressed about. That, my friends, is a whole post in itself.

I think what I'll try to do, instead, is take more time to comment on OTHER people's blogs (when they have them). That's really a better way to share the Comment Love than trying to respond to everyone here - unless they ask a specific question, or a response seems warranted. Y'all are right - who the heck has the time?

I don't get nearly the quantity of comments you do, and I don't have time to respond to each one. I generally e-mail folks back, unless my response really adds to the conversation. A private e-mail allows for a response that is more personal than my commenters would want seen on my blog. I probably have 15 or so regular commenters, most of whom have become close friends.

I had one (just one) post that elicited 40 comments, and I'm overwhelmed at the thought of responding to them all, although I want to. Ultimately, I can't let blog-time detract from family time. If I felt obligated to craft a perfect response to each and every comment, I'd probably end up not posting to my blog any more.

That said, I do appreciate hearing back from the bloggers I read every 10 to 20 comments I leave, if just to say, "I know you're a regular reader and thanks for being civil".
.-= Sadia´s last blog ..Learning to share =-.

I love getting a response, but I totally don't expect it, unless maybe I asked a direct question and there are only a handful of other comments. Responses from other commenters are nice, too.

OT: Do you read Nei Nei's blog? She's been in the hospital lately, and Taylor Lautner dropped by to see her!! I just about died lol
.-= mommymichael´s last blog ..Picture post =-.

I adore when someone responds to a comment I left, but I absolutely never expect it, regardless of the size of the blog. I know there have been tons of comments I wanted to respond to but something in life comes up and I don't and then I forget... and I get, like, maybe 2 comments per blog entry, if that. It happens. Don't spend another minute worrying about it. I think most of us are more interested in what you have to say in your posts and just prefer that you keep posting than fret about this. :)
.-= Candice´s last blog ..A Mustang, A Mustang, my kingdom for a Mustang =-.

I used to try to respond to everyone but like you, now that I have more comments I don't respond as much, unless I'm particularly moved to say something or someone asks me a direct question. But THEN I'm worried if they will read it if I only reply on my blog so I end up responding twice, once on my blog and once in a personal email. It gets time consuming and like I said somewhere around here recently, I put most of my energy into my posts and comments on other people's blogs and less into my replies. Sometimes all I want to say is thanks, but then I think I should really take the time to say something intelligent or more personal and if I don't have it in me I feel horribly guilty about it. I also find that the more I comment and reply the more personal emails I get, which is wonderful but also more time consuming. Ack! So I hope and cross my fingers that people will assume that I really am a very nice person and very grateful for their comments, but that I am busy and just can't do it all. Where did I put that Supermom "S"? I need it back!
.-= Melodie´s last blog ..Vegetarian Foodie Fridays: Lotus Land Linguine =-.

@Melodie - I think you just said a lot of what I didn't say. It does take a lot of energy to formulate a "smart" response, and that's often why I don't bother. I wanna just say "Hey! Thanks!" but then I feel pressured to say so much more. It might be better to try to comment on someone else's blog (if they have one) than to reply to every comment here. Plus, that's probably a good way to find like-minded bloggers.

I do not expect a reply from the blogger. In fact, I'm a "rare" commentor, but when I do I usually comment with the hope that my particular comment might make the blogger smile knowing someone (even if I'm among thousands) was touched /moved / inspired / etc. by what they wrote. Keep writing, I'll keep reading (I'm hooked) and every now and then I'll continue to send a comment warm fuzzy your way!!!

Thank you for the Warm Fuzzy. I'll take it any day :)

For me I'd rather get comments on my blog as a response than a "thanks for the comment" on their blog. Because then I know we are reading each others blogs rather than just me. :)

Now to tear through the rest of your entries to acquaint myself with your awesomeness!
.-= Keeshia´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday #5: Found & Growing =-.

Honestly, I don't care if no one ever responds to my comments. I don't come back to check them, honestly, because I just don't have that kind of time, usually. I read a lot of blogs. I know that lots of different bloggers have different response styles, and I don't sweat it. I, personally, only respond to a few. I sort of feel like my contribution was the blog post, and it's up to my readers to take the comments where they want to go, short of personal attacks or that sort of thing.
.-= Amber´s last blog ..I Can’t Believe I’m Talking about Epidurals =-.

I actually like that attitude - I Do the Bloggin, You Do the Respondin'. Makes sense to me!

I like this approach too! I do think most comments threads, once they become conversations, take on a life of their own. I'm still figuring out the balance on my own blog, and have thought about this on my mini 'break' last week.

As for commenting on other blogs, with the exception of specific questions, as Sarah points out, I don't generally expect a reply by the author. I do sometimes check back on the conversation, especially if it was a particularly lively one!
.-= Dou-la-la´s last blog ..Our Enormous Balls =-.

I think you are supernatural for being able to keep up with this blog while caring for two children. I have two of my own and I get NOTHING done, and by nothing, I really mean nothing. If you had the time to mother, blog AND respond to every comment, I may have to question if you are really human!

@StarryMom - Yee haw! Yes I do! I just wasn't sure if it was possible with my setup. You have the coolest-ever comment style on your blog, so I suppose you're capable of anything.

Do you want threaded comments?

I try and respond to all comments on my comments page. Granted I do most of that while nursing a sleepy sir nummies.

When it comes to commenting, unless I ask a specific question, I generally don't expect a response.
.-= Sarah @ OneStarryNight´s last blog ..Creating Your WordPress Theme — Part 1 =-.

I have to say, I do not have any kids. My fiance and I have been trying to get pregnant for months, with no success. Due to some medical issues we have to go through a fertility clinic, and the process has been quite emotionally and financially draining. I quit my insanely stressful job as a social worker in an attempt to help balance my life and help move things along. I am not even sure how I came upon your site, but it has been very helpful to me. I think I have left one comment, but I do not need a response ever. Reading your blog and all of the positive comments from everyone else is super helpful and I appreciate it so much.

@Jill - You know what YOU have on your blog that I DESPERATELY need? That nested comment thing. I gotta get that, I'm just not sure how. Is that a plugin? My blog template was handcrafted from the ground up, so it may not work the same as a standard template, but if there's a way, I gotta figure out how to get that thing. I feel like that feature would clean up my replies, ergo, encouraging me to leave them.

I actually got a comment-to-my-comment today, on another blog that I visit. I've never really thought about it before but once it happened it really makes you feel as if there's some sort of rapport with that person and you're not just another number on their blogcounter. So ya, acknowledgement is nice but it hasn't bothered me that there wasn't any before. Now...if the blog author is leaving comments to everyone BUT me? Ya, then I'd feel insulted.

I feel like this is an area I really lack in, too, especially since I got my Iphone. It used to be I could only approve and check comments from my WP dashboard on my computer, and that made it easier to reply, but it's next to impossible at a stop light while checking my phone. Personally, I don't get too offended when a blog author doesn't reply to me. I know they've got a lot of other things going on. It does irk a bit when it happens on Twitter consistently, but I think I just need to get over myself. I try my very best to reply to all tweets, but there are days that is just NOT a possibility, and I hope others will understand.

I actually think you're great about interacting on here, and have thought before that I need to be better "like you" about doing the same.
.-= Jill @BabyRabies´s last blog ..Out of the mouth of my babe =-.

It's nice when someone responds, but I never really expect it and it's no reason for me to stop following a blog.

But I'm not a blogger (well, I am, but not outside work) so I don't know if there's some kind of blogger code.

Hee hee. I was going to comment but I was worried you wouldn't answer. Oops. I just did comment.

I dunno Gina...I think it's about striking a balance. Certainly in conversation it is wonderful to be answered and acknowledged. But it's true, we're all busy and have a lot of other time demands. I think you're right to consider it just one of the associated tasks of blogging but I also think it's impossible to respond to all of the comments all of the time. Maybe it means 1-2 fewer posts each week or month so that comments can be addressed in that time? I dunno.
.-= Alison´s last blog ..Are YOU awesome? =-.

I don't mind at all not getting a comment back, especially not from a "famous" blog such as yours that attracts so many! I do comment back to my own commentors because I only get a few, but still, I find it quite time consuming even managing that!
.-= geekymummy´s last blog ..fast friends =-.