Hacker Impersonates Circle of Moms to Send Me Fraudulent Email

Jun 23rd 2011

If you think you’ve seen it all, think again. This week, some random stalker went so far as to hack in and forge an email directed to me from a major online parenting community.  Here’s the story…

Last week, I was voted in as the #2 Top Political Mom blogger at Circle of Moms.

Tuesday, I got an email from “Catherine” at Circle of Moms (with an email address of Catherine@CircleofMoms.com) telling me that they had made an error, and that I was not qualified as a “political” blogger, therefore they would be removing me from the Top 25.  The email stated,

“Because we value our good relationship with you and your readers, we are notifying you in advance that your blog, “The Feminist Breeder”, will be removed from the Top 25 Political Mom Blogs voting page on Tuesday, June 21 by 5:00 PM PST, and will not appear on the final list. We would like to give you the opportunity to inform your readers beforehand in order to minimize any misunderstanding that may occur as a result of our decision. We would appreciate your cooperation with this goal. Thank you again for your participation. We invite you to enter future Circle of Moms Top 25 Blog contests, and we look forward to continuing a positive working relationship with you.

Best,
Circle of Moms
118 2nd Street, 2nd Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
Twitter: @circleofmoms
www.facebook.com/circleofmoms”

I posted the note about it on Facebook, and several of my followers sent angry letters to Circle of Moms wanting to know WHY they would disqualify me when they were the ones who put me in the category in the first place.

The next day, I get another email from Circle of Moms claiming that they never disqualified me, and were happy to have me as one of their Top Political Bloggers. Part of that email read,

“It appears that someone not affiliated with Circle of Moms sent you that email. I’m so sorry that you experienced this, and can understand why you thought that email was legitimate, as the sender utilized our company information, etc. It’s unfortunate, but occasionally in our Top 25 programs there are violations of our policies, and participants that take inappropriate steps to compete. We do our best to police those situations, monitor social activity, and respond to user feedback to ensure all entrants are behaving in ways consistent with our No THUMPS and Blog with Integrity policies.

If you could send me the email that you received, we will do our best to determine the sender and resolve the situation.”

Honestly, it all sounded very Weiner-gate to me, so I forwarded them the first email I got from catherine@circleofmoms.com and said “Uh, See? This DID come from your domain.”

A few moments later they wrote back,

“It is looking like someone hacked into our servers; now that we have the email, our CTO is determining if he can identify the actual sender. I’ll know more either tonight or tomorrow, and will reach back out to you then.”

Okay. WHAT. THE. FUCK!?!?!

So, I wrote back to this “Catherine” person and told “her” that the real Circle of Moms was onto her, and good luck with that whole hacking-into-servers thing.

THEN, “Catherine” the hacker decided to get cute, and wrote back:


Seriously?  How NUTS is that?!?!

My own Web Ninja, StarryMom, explained to me that this “Catherine” person forged the email headers using an old hacker trick, which would allow any asshole to send email appearing to be anyone. That’s right – that means that someone could use this trick to send an email from YOU. It would have your name, and your company email address — and unless someone investigates the source of every email that comes into their inbox, they would just believe it’s you.

So, that’s the What. Now comes the WHY?

Why in the farking universe would someone impersonate a website to send me one VERY POLITE email apologetically explaining that they were forced to remove me from some stupid, totally inconsequential list? What was the purpose? If this person didn’t think I belonged on the Political Mom blogs list, then what did this help? I’m still on that list, and now this person has committed an internet crime. What did they get out of it? The pure satisfaction of trying to screw with me? Ummm… congratulations?

If that’s what gets you off, then I’m truly very sorry that your life sucks so badly that this is all you have to fill it up. I’m sorry that your delirious boredom forces you to  consider cyber-crime “fun stuff.” I hope you find prison equally as hilarious.

Every day, the internet shows me just how totally bat-shit psychotic people can be. All I can do is shake my head and hope I never come across these clearly-unstable people in person.

What do you make of this hot mess?

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Earth Mama Angel Baby


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I can really relate, because I too am being cyber-stalked by someone I know to have been diagnosed with BPD. She's been stalking me for about three and a half years and I'm losing hope that she'll ever leave me alone. Unfortunately I don't have any insight or advice. I just wanted to offer my sympathy/support because I know how much it sucks!

Oh, god, I feel really bad now after reading some of her pretty extensive writings. The woman you're talking about isn't bipolar, she's got borderline personality disorder, which is part of the cluster B personality disorders. It sounds like she's pretty aggressively seeking treatment, both medication and therapy. And like many people with significant mental issues, it sounds like she had good days and bad days.
BPD is a bitch. It is really difficult mental disorder to deal with, both for the person who has it and the people around them. Bipolar can be pretty successfully managed with medication, but BPD is so difficult to impact. And if you have BPD, you probably had some pretty horrific experiences in your childhood. The suicide rate for BPD is horribly high.
I feel bad for you that you have to deal with this, but I also feel really sorry for her that she's living with this diagnosis. I absolutely believe that mental illness is the right framework for this discussion -- not "jerk" or "pathetic" or other words like that.

Yes, you're probably right. I thought she told my husband that she was bipolar (YES, she tracked down my husband on facebook and sent him messages, along with speaking to my biological mother on another site.) She told my husband a month ago that she was sorry for "ruining" my life (as if she has that much power) and that she would stop all the bullshit she's been pulling. Then she was on Twitter today calling me names (before I blocked her AGAIN.)

That diagnosis is very sad for her and all, meanwhile I've been living with her stalking and harassment for the last half dozen years. I don't know her from Adam - she became obsessed with me from my band days - and has been popping up every so often to screw with me. I have to block her once every month or so because she creates fake email addresses and accounts and keeps coming after me. Two years ago I filed a police report after she went on a harassment rampage and then sent me creepy messages talking about where I live(d.)

I cannot prove that she was behind this latest one, but it's totally her MO. What's an innocent victim of one of these BPD people supposed to do about this? I'm honestly concerned that she's a Mark David Chapman, and it's only a matter of time before she tries to hurt me or my family. Every time I think that's an over-reaction, she pops back in and does insane stuff like this. What would you do?

If you email me, I can send some good info your way. I have a lot of personal experience dealing with people with BPD.

You probably mean well, but maybe Gina shouldn't be emailing random people from the blog if there is a person stalking her who is known to make up personas in order to get into her life?

Here are a few links that may be helpful:
http://lessonsinawareness.com/bpd.aspx -- a good overview of BPD. Pay particular attention to the part about splitting -- people with BPD tend to see others as all good or all bad, switching from total love to total devaluation.
http://blog.bennettandbennett.com/2010/07/10-practical-rules-for-dealing-with-the-borderline-personality.html -- dealing with a borderline
http://www.oprah.com/oprahshow/MOSAIC-Gavin-de-Beckers-Online-Threat-Assessment-Tool -- stalking threat assessment tool (ignore the fact that it's on the Oprah website, it's actually really good.)
http://www.angelfire.com/ga/random/bordr.html -- borderlines are really prone to stalking

And also, I read what your biomom wrote and I think you should definitely take a look at these and see if they ring any bells. I wouldn't be surprised if your mom had BPD.

http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Borderline-Mother-Unpredictable-Relationship/dp/0765702886

http://behavioralhealth.typepad.com/markhams_behavioral_healt/2007/06/children_cannot.html

http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200707/borderline-walking-the-line

Thanks for all the links.

Oh yeah, my bio-mom has all kinds of problems, but I haven't had enough contact with her to understand WHAT problems they are, and no matter how many run-ins she has with the law, nobody has ever thought to diagnose or treat her (that I know of). I'm not interested in understanding her - she's done too much damage to me already in the very limited contact I've had with her over the last 33 years. I just know that lying, thievery, abuse, delusions, hypochondria, narcissism, and addiction are all a part of her personality, which is why I cut contact with her long ago. I have my own family and mental health to worry about.

BPD is actually my area of expertise, even though I'm now working primarily with people with psychosis. I just wanted to say that you've said that very well.

However, it is appropriate to hold borderline people accountable for their behavior (in a fashion appropriate for their condition.) It's not a free ride to do whatever you want. Taking responsibility for their own feelings is critical to getting better. Yes, they are driven by intense, overwhelming anxieties, and they need and deserve help to get better. They also don't have a free ride to hurt others.

Holy crap that's freaky stuff! I hope they figure out who it was. Nutbar is right! I'm sorry you had to waste your time with all that nonsense.

Wow. This is so horrifyingly invasive and unfair. It's situations like this that really make me believe (or hope) that Karma exists. Regardless if this women is actually diagnosed in the DSM IV or not, she is clearly showing signs of unstable behaviour, being that you are the VICTIM of said behaviour, you have all rights to label it as YOU see it! Best of luck, and I truly hope this does not continue.

Totally agree with Jeneria.

I agree with those who are asking that mental health terms not be used in this discussion and I think it's irresponsible to try and armchair diagnose. I'm bipolar, but I would never do anything like this. Don't brush all bipolars with such a broad stroke. It's hard enough having a diagnosis of bipolar without others using the term to denounce behavior they don't find acceptable (I put it in the same category as "retarded" and "gay.")

I'm sorry that this happened to you. But it doesn't take a mental illness for someone to do something like this. Some people are just assholes.

If this is the person I think it is, she IS bipolar. She blogs openly about it. It's not my diagnosis, it's her doctor's, as she says. But I don't personally believe this particular behavior is a manifestation of bipolar disorder. It simply seems sociopathic to me, and THAT would be an armchair diagnosis. I can't think of any other way to make sense of it.

I think the term you're looking for might be sociopath. They know what they are doing is wrong and get their jollies from it, knowing it's wrong.
http://www.mcafee.cc/Bin/sb.html

Bipolar is a pretty wastebasket diagnosis these days. I don't trust most of the diagnoses to be accurate. And even if she is bipolar, that doesn't mean every single thing she does is a result of bipolar behavior, as you said. Flat out sociopath (which is not a true mental health diagnosis, but rather a social descriptor) seems more accurate, though, we don't know.
What we do know is that it's mean, nasty behavior. Why isn't it enough to just say that? People can choose to do wrong things just because they are twisted and WANT to, not because they have mental illness.

It looks like she has borderline personality disorder (BPD, which I mistook to bi-polar disorder - my mistake.)

I have very personal experience with bipolar being a wastebasket diagnosis, as I was once diagnosed bipolar and medicated with Depakote until a much smarter doctor realized that I am NOT bipolar, I'm just a Type-A personality with depressive tendencies stemming from my abused childhood exacerbated by hormone imbalances and hypothyroidism. So, yeah. I know a little about that.

I googled the person's name out of curiosity and found her twitter account where she talks openly about having borderline personality disorder (BPD) which is different from bipolar disorder (although maybe she is also bipolar?).

Wow. Just wow. I just read the Mama Tao website and the parody blog and wow. There are some serious untreated mental disorders going on there. I'm reading that shit and I'm like, "Cluster B personality disorder? Bipolar?"
Seriously, it's not just mean or spiteful or pathetic or whatever. It shows the thought patterns of a legitimate mental disorder.

Out of curiousity, what patterns do you see that indicate mental disorders on the Mama Tao blog? To me, it's satire- occasionally immature, to be sure, but still just satire. Are you a therapist? (Not trying to be snarky, I am actually curious).

....what is this I don't even

That's quite freakily weird!

This insane! People need to get a life. What a waste of your time, that you don't have to waste.

As someone who works with psychotic people daily, I have to say, it's not "psychotic" at all. Pyschotic people are ill and their behavior, when it is driven by their illness, is not under their control This is cold and calculated. It's just mean and nasty. That's a totally different deal.

It's also exceedingly pathetic.

I'm no expert, but after doing a quick google search of this person, I don't think "psychotic" is too far off.

I am an expert (my profession involves working with truly psychotic people daily), and psychotic is completely off.

Maybe it was one of those people who called us all commies...those mindsets get a kick out of fucking with people and watching your reaction to it. Sad, but that is just how it is.

Am I the only one to notice that the majority of people who do this crap are women? Ive yet to figure out why we cant support and empower each other - even if our views are different.

I think you are seeing that based on what you happen to read. If you look at male dominate sites you see plenty of appalling behavior from guys. Also, on the internet you can claim to be anyone. She could actually be a man pretending to be a woman in the online persona. I don't think we need to dump the blame on women--sadly, there's plenty of deserved blame to go around.

That's crazy to think someone can do that! And rather scary! Yikes!

I'm sorry this has happened to you, and I'm glad it's being sorted. But could we please leave ableist slurs like "psycho(tic)" out of it? :o/

I'd love to think of another word. Help me think of another word. What do you call a person who commits these types of behaviors? What is their condition, if not psychosis?

Gina, as I've said below, it's absolutely nothing like psychosis, which involves loss of contact with reality, usually with delusions and/or hallucinations. It can result in extreme mental and cognitive disorganization. This is completely well thought out, organized, and just plain mean. If you want a mental health term, it's exceedingly antisocial.

She knows it's wrong. She has no delusions, hallucinations, or anything of the kind. She's just wanting to mess with you. Sometimes the simplest words are best. She's mean, she nasty, she's pathetic.

As Maria implied here, it is ableist to assume that behaviour we don't like is automatically a result of some sort of mental illness, rather than that person simply being a jerk. I'd try words that have nothing to do with mental illness to be honest. Maria gave you a few.

I have reason to believe that this person is a long-time stalker named Lisa Ann Jarrett, who is clinically bi-polar, and writes a blog about it. I filed a police report against her for the same type of crap two years ago. She messages me (AND MY FAMILY MEMBERS) at least once a month, and every time I block her, she creates new accounts and finds new ways to contact me. She even knew where I lived and made threatening comments about coming to my last home (which is why I filed the report.) She sends messages telling me that she's sorry for trying to "ruin" my life, and then sends messages the next day calling me names. If she's not behind this, then someone very similar is, and based on all the communications I received from this person, I absolutely believe they are deluded. I believe they actually convinced themselves they were a CoM employee before I told them I knew better. I think THAT's when they snapped back to reality, and, as seen above, they clearly showed no remorse even when getting caught. This person doesn't think there's anything wrong with this behavior. Anti-social? Bi-polar? If it's Lisa Ann Jarrett, then all of the above, and that's the official diagnosis.

How sad. Just think of all the amazing things we could accomplish if losers like this used their talent and time to do something useful in this world. Pathetic.

All I can say is "psycho"

Who has time for this kind of crap? How sad and lonely and full of self-hate do you have to be?

Creepy!! It's scary when you think about the fact that these psychos are out walking the streets. If it makes you feel any better my email address was hacked 2 days ago. I don't know how/why that happened but the person sent EVERYONE in my address book an email asking if they remembered our sweet sexual encounter and had some link obviously for a virus. Yeah, *everyone* as in not just friends and family but colleagues, former coworkers, my baby's pediatrician... :-(

I am speechless. Some people have way too much free time on their hands!

Re. Donk. U. Lous. I can't believe people don't have better things to do with their precious time.

In your web browser you can probably do something like "View" "Message Source" and then look through and see where the e-mail was actually sent from and how it's not legit. Look at Return path and other info. Sometimes you'll see that e-mails are coming from .uz like for uzbeckistan or .ce for the Czech republic (I think). But with the one you got, you probably wouldn't think to question it -- I probably wouldn't. Prob a teen with or disgruntled reader w/ too much time on their hands.

Shit like this is why there is STILL no cure for cancer: losers like this "Catherine" hot mess, sitting on their fat asses, using their limited time on Earth doing useless crap like hacking for shits and giggles. For the love of fuck, "Catherine," go think something...quick!

Yes, it is very simple to impersonate an email address, and does not involve hacking a server at all, but most spam filters filter them due to other tricks that try to verify that the email came from the IP address of the domain it was sent from.

What doesn't make senses is when you replied the reply really would have gone to the circle of mom's server and landed in the inbox for that address if it exists. Unless the hacker replaced the email address in the reply-to spot. Most email applications have an option that allow you to see the original message with all the headers (from your screen shot maybe under the other actions link). Look at the email address in the line that says Reply-to:. If it is the same catherine@circleofmoms.com address then either someone really did hack into their server to read and respond to your reply, or it really came from ctherine at circle of moms, or I don't know as much as I think I do (but I don't think that is the case).

Wow that is truly insane. It's kind of sick actually. It completely baffles me as to why on Earth someone would go through all the trouble to do something so asinine. Glad it got "sorted" Ha!

My first thought was that the email really did come from circle of moms and when they got all the complaint letters from your readers and the bad press for their site, they decided to make up a fake hacker to excuse the email. Something to think about...

Maybe the goal was to tell you your blog was out so all your readers would get pissed & contact them. Maybe they thought these reactions would be enough to get you kicked out for real. Or maybe it was a disgruntled employee stirring up shit. Who knows.

Y'know, maybe the whole thing WAS legit. They really did decide you were ineligible. But after your post (and backlash from your loyal, angry readers), they decided to save face and reinstate you- while making up the hacker story? Then 'Catherine' was pissed at COM after being let go and sent you those taunting emails to make them look bad? I mean, it's crazy, but... no more crazy than any other option.

Holy fucking shit! The fact that she took that much time out of her life to screw with you.... In a perverted yet frustrating way, that's almost flattering. So glad you're still in it, though! Sorry you had to go through this... I appreciate you giving us a lesson in hacking! I had no clue....

What can appear bat-shit crazy to you can seem perfectly normally everyday stuff to someone else. A friend of mine thought it would be funny to make posts for free stuff like blackberry torches, guitars, or stripper poles on kijiji (I think americans don't have kijiji, so if this is true, I could be wrong, it is the equivilant of craigslist, only fancier). Anyway they posted all their numbers or emails. This isn't the exact same thing as what happened to you but when it happned I couldn't understand why someone would take the time to do that. People can be entertained by the silliest of things because to them it's not so silly. Maybe they did it to see you're reaction, see if maybe you'd write a whole post about it.

I couldn't have said it better myself. It was a silly contest to begin with. In a way I think they won Gina. Now they have a whole post. People are crazy and have nothing better to do. Just be thankful that you have 3 children, a husband, and classes to keep you moving forward.