I’m Birthing at Home and Eating My Placenta, and I Swear I’m Not Even a Hippy

Jan 16th 2011

When I think of hippies, I think of “free spirited” people who wear long skirts, sport patchouli instead of makeup, and maybe pray to a mystical Earth Goddess (instead of the Gods of Capitalism the way most Americans do.)  They may have followed the band Phish, spent a good part of their 20′s smoking “herbs”, and only eat food grown on their compound.  They don’t like corporations, and will happily spend time making all their own clothes.  And I’m willing to bet their record collection contains at least one Ani DiFranco album, along with the entire Bob Dylan and Grateful Dead catalogs.

I have a whole bunch of friends who I consider crunchy hippies, who proudly wear the badge.  I admire them and their relaxed way of life, so trust me when I say I’m not implying that there’s anything wrong with being a hippie, that’s just not my bag.  I’m not a “free spirit.” I’m an anxious, cranky, Type-A personality whose sarcastic humor resembles more Lewis Black than George Carlin.  I don’t like the band Phish.  I never wear long skirts.  I. Cannot. Sew. I LOVE wearing makeup (preferably the ridiculously expensive kind that I can no longer afford.)  And I never did enjoy smoking “herbs.”  I also have no talent for gardening, and can think of 100 ways I’d rather spend my time.  If I ever ended up a POW, and the enemy was looking for a way to torture me, strapping me to a chair and forcing me to listen to Bob Dylan songs might be one way to go about it.  I am a Riot Grrrl – NOT an Indigo Girl.

And in my uninformed youth, I assumed that only the “crunchy hippies” as I described above would do crazy shit like willingly have a baby at home (where there are no drugs???? WHAT?!?!) and willingly ingest their own placenta (Okay, now you’re just being weird for the sake of it – FREAK!)

I used to compare med-free birth to med-free dentistry, as in WHY would anyone get a tooth pulled with no Novocaine?  (As it turns out, I learned that having an epidural is nothing at all like getting a shot of Novocaine, and having a baby is in no way comparable to having a tooth pulled out.  Whoops!)

And then I started breastfeeding. And then I started cloth diapering.  Then, I started making my own baby food.  Next, I was wearing my baby.  Then, I planted a small (failed) garden with my kids.  And then I started planning a homebirth.  And to top it all off, I hired someone to encapsulate my placenta — so that I can eat it.

Whoa.

And there is so much cognitive dissonance that comes with traveling this far away from the type of person you *thought* you were, and engaging in the behaviors of someone who you believe belongs to a subculture you don’t fit in with.  Then you find yourself questioning everything you thought you knew about your place in the world.  “But Gina, okay, wait… if only Hippies have a homebirth, and you’re having a homebirth, then ergo, doesn’t that make you a hippie now?  I mean, you ARE cloth diapering your kid!  But this cannot be!  I could never wear patchouli!  Aaaaahhhh!  What’s happening to me?!?!”

Well perhaps, just maybe, homebirth isn’t just for hippies? Maybe there’s some good reason that a makeup-and-miniskirt-wearing, Type-A personality would willingly choose to have a baby in fishy pool parked in her living room?  And maybe she also has some good reason for taking pills made out of her very own placenta?  Maybe none of it has anything to do with being vegan or praying to a Moon Goddess after all?

Well, these are my good reasons:

  • I’m choosing a med-free water birth in my living room because the safety record of that mode of delivery is both evidenced-based, and supported by science.  In fact, a homebirth is the perfect choice for a picky Type-A who likes to control her environment whenever possible.  I can have a safe, joyful birth at home that could be far more pleasant than either of my two miserable hospital experiences where the “Novocaine” turned out to be a train wreck and the damn nurses kept me awake all night with their beeping machines.  I can push a baby out into a warm bath, with a highly trained Midwife personally safeguarding my experience, as I’m surrounded by people who are all 100% focused on ME.  No “free spirit” or Bob Dylan records required.
  • I’m encapsulating my placenta because scientific research shows that it can have enormous benefits for my health, including reducing my risk for that damned postpartum depression, and helping to boost my milk supply.  My Type-A personality prefers to steer clear of mind-altering drugs anyway, so if there’s a way to keep my own feel-good chemicals in my body, then by all means, I will try that way first.  And I do NOT have to cut off chunks of this veiny thing and put them in a hippy-dippy kale and beet smoothie.  Nope!  I can just pop a couple of pills that look like vitamins, which just so happen to contain an organ of mine.  No big, hairy deal.

So, in revealing my formerly misguided judgments, my hope is that more “mainstream” women will get hip to the fact that these birthing choices are not reserved for a select group of women who some might think of as “fringe” characters.  You don’t have to be a card-carrying hippy to consider having a safer, more natural birthing experience.  You don’t have to be “anti-establishment” to consider placentophagy as a way to fight postpartum mood issues.  You can still your wear make-up, or business suits, or even stilettos.

And maybe in years to come, women from all walks of life will see homebirth as one of the many legitimate birthing choices available to them.  And maybe placenta encapsulation will be prescribed by doctors and paid for by insurance if the average, American woman starts demanding it.  And maybe more women will consider cloth diapering and wearing their babies because there are real health benefits to both.

And on that day, maybe I can stop trying to explain to people that, while I do like homebirth, I swear on my life I’m never going to start sewing my own floor length skirts.  I’m still a Riot Grrrl, and I’ll always be partial to skin-tight minis.

___________________________________________________

*I really hope all my hippie friends can see the humor in this, and not be offended at my verbal caricature of the subculture.  I’m just trying to illustrate a point for the masses.  Much love for ya, my hippie mama friends!

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Earth Mama Angel Baby


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
HaruhiSuoh 5 pts

Love this! So excited to be a mommy...hopefully someday soon! ^_^

How lovely it is to come across someone like myself. I'm a midwifery student right now, who is very scientific and very much not a hippy. However when I tell people my views about childbirth and pregnancy they look at me like I'm crazy. Keep on spreading the good word, I'll definitely be following your blog.

Awesome, awesome post! I planned for a home birth. I wanted to encapsulate my placenta, and hired a specialist to do it; however, when I opted to birth in the hospital (because of being in early labor and excruciating pain for a ridiculously long time) the damn hospital wouldn't let me take my placenta with me! I was so angry! They called it "medical waste" and refused to let me take it home. BOO!!

I love your point about making home birth a more mainstream option. Also, placenta encapsulation should be covered by insurance!

Hope you have an amazing type A home birth! :)

I really admire those who actually eat the placenta, I couldn't imagine doing it myself, so I decided to opt for placenta encapsulation. I have to say that it was a life saver and I'm sooo glad I did it with my second pregnancy.

I get very excited when I find people out there like you. And let me tell you, I haven't seen anyone use Riot Grrrl in a long time! I am currently a sahm to six boys. Never in my life did I think I would feel and think the way I do now about things. I'm a co-sleeping, baby wearing, breastfeeding mom that made her own baby food and wished I had the balls to homebirth. (the hippy skirts are only because they are cooler in the summer and hide my fat parts so nicely). I wish I had heard about the placenta eating before now. I had bad post partum with the last one and I'm very against having to take medications when there is a natural alternative. I think we are the new hippys. Not the 60s version with the pot smoking and woodstock, but we seem to be taking a step back from the commercialized way to raise children.

Me too! Well, almost... I have no plans to eat the placenta in any form, but I DO plan to put it in the yard under a tree or something.

And while I'm decidedly not a hippy (I always forget my reuseable bags and I get my legs waxed regularly at a chichi spa), I have conceded that I'm a little bit crunchy. Like one of those super sweet chewy granola bars with chocolate chips.

I love this post! Believe it or not, I actually just wrote an article for my local community weekly newspapers that covers this exact same topic...

"The midwife model of care views birth as a natural and normal process, albeit one that requires training and skill to successfully support. Midwives provide non-drug pain relief techniques including massage, water therapy, and guided relaxation.

While these techniques—and homebirth in general—sometimes conjures images of hippies giving birth in a commune, many of the people involved in homebirth are not as crunchy-granola as one might think."

Full article here:
http://www.sonomawest.com/articles/2011/01/18/living/doc4d2e02b04f12e937826983.txt

(By the way, I read your blog all the time, I'm not just some drive-by poster. I don't comment too much because I'm not yet pregnant and don't have kids, so sometimes I feel a little silly about it... But, I felt like I had to post this, because my article literally published last Thursday and it was some kind of mental synergy here! I had such a blast interviewing doulas and midwives, and spent WAY too much time reporting for this article.)

a sort-of-hippie, sort-of-suburban-girl turned farmer, goat midwife and journalist (who needs labels anyway?!),

Lynda

That's so awesome! Thank you for linking article!

Awesome, awesome, awesome!!! Thank you for writing this!!!!!

My husband calls me a hippie all of the time! The truth is, though, I am not. I am just a person who appreciates evidence-based practice and believes that the more we work with the way our bodies are designed, the better our health will be. I also like to save money.
I birthed naturally, breastfeed exclusively until 8 months, babywear, use cloth diapers and EC, drink raw milk, and eat a mostly "traditional" food diet. I prefer calf-length skirts, lol. (not long or short!) Balance is key, but mostly our culture has lost a sense of what is a balanced life. Any person who tries to buck the current viewpoint is accused of being "crunchy", a hippie, etc. Seriously, do you know how much money I've saved doing EC alone?!

Brilliant post Gina! You are opening minds and by opening minds you are helping open doors in the childbirth community.
thank you :-)

Thanks for the post. So very humerous, to the point, factual, and very very well put. I'm not a hippie but rather, like you, very Type A personality in need of being in control which is why I did give birth to my second child at home ON PURPOSE! I went to med school as part of my training and work in the medical profession as a high level practitioner and could not believe more strongly that sick people belong in hospitals - not low risk moms giving birth. You're awesome!! Keep up the commentary :)

Hey! Thanks for your post! I am also a homebirther that is not quite a hippy. Thanks for trying to bring homebirth mainstream!

Hi, I have only just found this blog but had to comment on this. My husband is always joking that since becoming pregnant I have become increasingly hippy! It started with a homebirth (which ended up in hospital but that's by the by) and at 21 months we still breastfeed and co-sleep. I have changed all my cleaning products to natural ones and our son wears an amber necklace. I plan to start making my own clothes and soaps this year and dream of having a garden. Anyway I digress, the point is that it is wonderful that those things that have long been the reserve of crunchy hippies are edging into the mainstream.
BTW, I hate patchouli!

Oh you know, I'm a artsy, earthy, crunchy hippie & proud of it.
Okay, except for the Phish part. I totally wear pachouli. And the Indigo Girls rock, yo... their harmonies Gina, you gotta love em.
(But hey, I have Veruca Salt & Hole in my collection too, judge me not).
Anyhow, I LOOOOOOOVE this post because it's so real, and echoes a lot of feelings I had before I was as cool as I am now. ;)
I wish I had thought that homebirthing & doulas weren't "weird" when I was pregnant with my first (I've come a lonnnnnng way). I wish that ALL the options for birth were presented to women - that hospitals weren't the default. That women understood that birthing is okay and wonderful and something they can handle.

Funny story - the entire reason that Nina & Louise (Veruca Salt's founders) hired a bassist and drummer was that they were signing acoustic duets in a club and someone came up to them and said "Oh! It's just like the Indigo Girls!" and they were HORRIFIED. They were like "NO NO NO NO NO! We are ROCK girls, not FOLK girls." So, they hired a bassist and drummer, plugged in their guitars, and promptly recorded and released the album American Thighs, named after (what else?) an AC/DC song.

They had to prove to people that they weren't hippies, and in the process, helped bring some girl rock back into the mainstream. Love it. :)

I am right there with you! I am excited to hear what you think of placenta encapsulation. I just did it for my third birth and it was amazing!

Great blog. and ditto! I will have a home birth too and dont wear long skirts :)

too funny! I wouldn't really consider myself a hard-core hippy (but compared to many here in eastern NC, we are very hippy) but I had a home birth. It was amazing! And while I'm not going to eat my placenta, it remains in our freezer (for almost a year now) as we decide what to do with it!

Like you, I am probably the farthest thing from "crunchy" except now in my attached parenting style, choice to feed my family organic healthy food, and probably so many other things that make me fall right on that line....so to you I say....YOU GO GIRL!

Great post! As someone who suffered horribly from PPPTSD after the birth of my 2nd child, I have decided that I will be doing the placenta encapsulation, as well. My midwife will be making some kind of shake (and 3 of my friends swear by it), as well. We'll see how it goes.

As with everything else in life, you make the best decision for yourself...mainstream or not. I applaud you for doing your research and going with what is best for you. I am currently 39.2 weeks along with twins and will be having them at home, as well. I was only given 2choices for a hospital birth: scheduling a section at 37 weeks regardless od circumstances OR being allowed to "attempt" a natural birth, in the OR, on my back with an epidural. You are very right when you say that a lot of hospitals simply do not give the choice of birthing options to the patients. So after a lot of research and ver careful, thorough monitoring, I will have my twins at home (barring any unforeseen circumstances, of course)!

Can't wait to hear about your birth!

I'm a hippie - though you might not know it to look at me. I don't wear patchouli or makeup (except maybe for special occassions). My uniform is more of a jeans and t-shirt thing with the occasional handmade item thrown in - but I buy them from local women and don't sew my own clothes. I do a lot of sewing though - and happily make things for my children and for sale.

Both of my children were born at home. My version of normal as my mother had 2 HB's (HBA3C x 2) - and I got to watch when I was 9. Kind of defined normal childbirth for me.

I cloth diapered both babies - and started a business making and selling cloth diapers too. I extended BF (they were 4 and 3 when they weaned). I baby wore, co-slept etc etc...

Currently we grow most of our own food, have chickens, and try to live as sustain-ably as possible. I haven't used a disposable menstrual product in almost a decade (in fact I make and sell cloth pads).

The irony is I don't call myself a hippie in my day to day life. Where we live the word has some fairly negative connotations - notably lazy and dirty - which is a shame because the positives are a wonderful way of life and the choices we've made that are so different from the mainstream were not made without plenty of research and discussion.

You Sooo sound like me! I joke all the time that I'm more of a chewy granola bar! Especially since I'm getting ready to have my sixth(1st homebirth)... I must be Amish right... Not hardly. I'm a Christian, but not a religious fanatic either! When I'm not pregnant I enjoy a glass of wine in my whirlpool tub to wind down. I give Kudos to those who homeschool, but I couldn't do it. I'd LIKE to have a garden and prob will try it someday but find the produce section at Walmart completely acceptable... As well as the meat dept! So I'm a SAHM who likes having babies naturally, and parenting naturally, I'm not weird... I actually to a lot of research that leads me to my choices rather than just following mainstream. Thanks for letting me feel not so alone!

i am right there with you sister! i gave birth to my beautiful daughter at home 3 months ago and it was awesome. and i am anything but hippy! actually, when i was a teenager i was a full fledged punk rocker that didn't like any music unless it was fast, fast, fast! i wear heels, in fact, i think i was born in heels, i think 9 out 10 times when people meet them me, they assume that i am one of those girly girls who wouldn't garden for fear of breaking a nail. funny though because i love to fish and hike and horseback ride and mosh and stage dive. i own a big burly dog and would never have one of those dogs that fit in a purse. people have me all wrong and when they heard about my homebirth i think they about sh*t their pants! lol! all that aside, i wouldn't change it for anything in the world. i am shy and private and loved being in a dark, cozy room giving birth to my child with only mu husband and two midwives present. i think i am going to go watch the video now.. feel like reminiscing! good luck to you.. i am sure it will be life changing as it was for me :-)

okay, so by the descriptions above I 'might' be a bit of a hippie. however, I've never liked the smell of patchouli and I tend to be a type A personality. I love this so much, I'm sharing it on facebook!

Love this! Regardless of how you ultimately choose to birth I think it's really important to open yourself up to all the possibilities that are out there and take some time to consider the benefits and risks they carry. This post is sure to open some eyes to new possibilities; yea!

Except for my nose ring, I am a hippie in disguise :D I wear cute jeans and tops, jewelry, I dye my hair (from blonde to red) and wear makeup almost every day (sometimes it's five o'clock before I get a shower).

I homebirthed my third have been using a diva cup for five years and encapsulated my own placenta this time and even swallowed some raw peices to help with hemmorhaging! I now encapsulate placentas as part of my doula business and it's AWESOME!! I love seeing the gorgeous placentas and marvel over their amazingness. IT boggles my mind. I <3
placentas!

I LOVE this post! Sometimes I feel so fringe compared to my friends IRL because I like cloth and breastfeeding and natural birth and baby-wearing. And I'm not willing to let my 9 month old cry for hours till he falls asleep. They really look down on me like I'm some kind of freak. I live in suburbia, drive an (albeit fuel-efficient) minivan, I sometimes I even wear a string of pearls. I have the street cred. of a crunchity crunch hippie and a yuppie soccer mom all at the same time.

When I'm down on myself I feel like I don't fit in anywhere but the reality is I'm me. Take it or leave it.

So I totally wrote this comment and then ran an errand where I ran into a woman carrying her son in an Ergo, struck up conversation and felt like she might actually 'get me'! (Not that I don't love eFriends too, but sometimes face-to-face is key...)

That kid is gonna be pissed that you had a pool in your living room once and got rid of it right after the kid was born. How fun would it be to have a pool... IN YOUR LIVING ROOM.

p.s. encapsulation, huh? We'd have to figure out a way to do this so my husband doesn't find out, because he will collapse from the shock and divorce me afterwards.

I encapsulate placentas and many moms always say their husbands are skeeved out by the idea of it at first, especially when they hear the cost involved. My husband was too at first but then he a) saw the work that's involved in encapsulating a placenta and b) saw and experienced the benefits. He's now a changed man as are 99% of my client's male partners. :)

I am a merino and cashmere-wearing, stiletto and platform-sporting, Chanel-spraying, MAC-painting, church-going, Infiniti-driving mom who has four different baby slings/wraps, makes all food from scratch (including granola,) thinks baby food is a crock, breastfeeds until they wean themselves, wants to flip off epidurals, won't keep fruit juice in the house, thinks midwives are the shiz, is planting a garden, likes babies next to her in bed, and hates nursing covers.

I defy everything. So do you. Isn't it lovely?

Hear, hear! The reason why I do what I do is spelled out by you so frickin eloquentely: that more women would be empowered to have safer, more positive birth experiences--whether they're hippie or not-so-hippie!

I do get a bit annoyed when I frequently hear anything that's not "mainstream" referred to as "hippie" or "crunchy." Not that I have anything against hippies (heck, one of bff's is a bonafide hippie!). But it really does such a disservice to women and babies! Birth and parenting is universal. Sidenote--I found it quite funny when a good friend of mine made mention of me to a new mom who was contemplating using an amber teething necklace. My good friend said something like, "Sarah uses one on her baby," to which the new mom replied, "Yeah, but Sarah's kinda a little hippie," and then my friend corrected her and said, "Actually no, she's not a hippie!!" :) Why should reducing your baby's teething discomfort in a natural way be associated with being a hippie?!?

I had my placenta encapsulated after my last birth (horrible PPD after 1st birth) and it was like a DREAM come true. Totally different experience. I will never, ever give birth again without also encapsulating my placenta. Happy placenta love to you!

I am the child of hippies. And so I have very mixed feelings in admitting my own hippie-ness, to be honest. I do a lot of hippie things, but there were also many times in my youth when I wished I was allowed to drink regular apple juice. Or when I was embarrassed because my friends gagged at the carob 'treats' on offer at my house.

I try to walk a more middle road, myself. I think that's OK. And anyway, labels are for file folders, not people.

Indeed, labels are for file folders. Good one. I was going to say something similar.

Here I am thinking I was a hippie!! But since I don't wear patchouli or smoke herb or listen to Phish or The Grateful Dead, now I feel so mainstream. Geez, thanks for popping my bubble Gina! ;)

Haaa haaa - well maybe Canadian hippies are different. What's the Canadian equivalent of Phish? ;)

I love this. I can be a a hip, fun, funky mom who also breastfeeds until they self-wean, cloth diapers, co-sleeps, baby (and toddler) wears, and births at home. I can help a mom with breastfeeding questions while wearing some supa cute heels! We don't all have to wear Birkenstocks and braids! I'm so glad to finally be finding other moms who are more like me! :-)

If only doctors were taught the facts about homebirth in medical school! Almost every doctor I've spoken to about homebirth cringes and feels compelled to convince me that homebirth is bad because of the awful things they have personally seen in the NICU. Little do they know that those things are both in the minority and often caused BY the doctors rushing things and doing things unnaturally. So aggravating!

I had never heard the benefits of the placenta-eating before though! I might need to consider that for my next baby...

Sounds like me, I call it conservative with granola roots!

love this, so in line with my personal beliefs as well!

Ha! This was great! I too a non-hippie.... but one who has had two homebirths and is passionate (PASSIONATE!!!) about the amazing benefits of placenta medicine (did placenta smoothies AND placenta encapsulation after my second birth). My only regret is that I threw out my first placenta! NEVER AGAIN!!!! Thanks for writing! (Here is my placenta medicine story: http://birthingathome.blogspot.com/2009/09/further-adventures-in-placentophagy.html )

Love it! I can identify w/a lot of this, as I too had that realization: "Wait, if I had a homebirth, cloth diaper, breastfeed, make my own organic babyfood, babywear...does this mean I'm a hippy?"

Again, not that there's anything wrong with hippies--it's just not me. Like you, I'm way too type-A and anxious to be a hippy. But as far as my birth/parenting choices go, I pretty much look like a hippy to most of my friends.

I remember a conversation with my midwife, at one of my prenatal visits before my homebirth. She told me that more & more of her clients are nothing like that "hippy" stereotype--rather, they're really intellectual nerdy people like mathematicians, scientists, lawyers, etc. who've done their homework, read the research, know the facts and made an educated informed decision to birth at home. They aren't people birthing at home just for the "atmosphere", as many people seem to assume.

Can I get a bumper sticker that says "I didn't choose homebirth just so I could burn lavender-scented candles and chant mantras--Ask me why I really chose homebirth" ?

You rock- my next birth will be at home for sure. Still not sure about the placenta- I'll see how it goes for you :)

I am quite familiar with both NIH and ACOG guidelines regarding VBAC. I support home birth and VBAC. I am a VBA2C mother. My point is you cannot extrapolate data from hospital VBAC to HBAC. I am not even saying that HBAC is an inherently bad idea, I believe that is an individual's choice, although not one I would choose. I acknowledge that someone may be considered low risk, particularly if they've had a successful VBAC in the past. There is no data for HBAC, so my point is, you cannot state that HBAC safety is evidence-based by quoting hospital VBAC numbers.

Dr. Poppy, the current research on uterine rupture statistics does not qualify the incidents of uterine rupture based on where they occurred or did not occur. It simply calculates the reported incidents against the total number of birthing mothers. There exists no data that I know of to suggest that more uteruses rupture at home, or that there is a higher infant or maternal mortality rate based on where the mother births EXCEPT to suggest that the rate of complications is lower if she can be operated on within a given time period. Mothers laboring at home with skilled support and access to emergency transfers have, as far as the research suggests, the same chances that a mother laboring in the hospital does. Let me know if you do find any studies proving that planned homebirth with a skilled midwife and transfer services still show a higher rate of cesarean-related complications. Until then, I will use the best available evidence on TOLAC beside the best available evidence for planned homebirth to draw my conclusion, which is all anyone can do without a dedicated study on the matter.

Dr. Poppy, I would have to assume that the UR rate would be lower among HBACers than VBACers. Why? Women who give birth at home are not going to be artificially induced, have their labors augmented with oxytocic agents, or have their labors masked (and potentially altered) with epidurals. Women need to understand that these are contraindicated in most cases for TOLAC - many don't.

It's encouraging to read that you had a VBAC after 2 cesareans. I do not have access to a hopsital VBAC after 2 cesareans. It's not because of my hospital - it's because of local practice.

When 1% of a population is doing something in a particular way - I don't think it qualifies as a fad. My husband & I are just not willing to be cut out of our health care decisions. We're deciding to have our baby at home with assistance from two skilled midwives and a doula.

GREAT POST, TFB! ;)