Saying Goodbye to the Bink

Apr 20th 2010

Some people call it a pacifier.  Some people call it a Binky.  We simply called it a Bink.

They’ve been in my life for nearly 4 years.  When Jonas was born in 2006, the hospital sent us home with one of those handy-dandy breastfeeding-sabotaging formula bags, which contained at least a dozen shiny new Binks.  They immediately became a staple in our home, and our son latched on to them far better than he ever did to me.

The Bink was a lifesaver in the sleep department.  Starting at 6 weeks I could just plug up his mouth, swaddle him tight, and he’d sleep all the way through the night (which was especially useful because I was already back at work by then, and really needed sleep myself.)  Jonas loved the Bink the way most kids love blankies.  It was his little piece of security and comfort.

But I didn’t want my child to walk around with a Bink in his mouth when he was old enough to be drinking from a cup.  Just before his brother was born, we got Jonas to give up the Bink during the day.  He only used it for nap time and Night-Night time.  We were on the road to recovery.

Then, Jules was born.  Julesy also took to the Bink, even though he was exclusively breastfed.  I got lucky; he had no nipple confusion and my supply was great.  Julesy came  to love the Bink the same way Jonas did, which was a huge help for me because if Jules had his way about it, even at nearly 2, he’d be latched to my nipple 24 hours a day.  The Bink was the only way my boobs could catch a break.

But because Julesy used a bink during the day, it was hard to stop Jonas from doing the same.  Jonas would find them laying around, or even steal them right out of his brother’s mouth.  Last fall the Dentist told Jonas he had to stop using the bink or his teeth were going to be crooked, and that worked for a little while (he really liked the dentist and wanted to please her, that little weirdo).  But before long, the Dentist’s pep talk wore off, and we were right back to where we started with my preschooler trying to suck on a Bink all day long.

I’ve known I needed to take the hard road and get rid of the Binks all together, but, if I’m being perfectly honest with myself, I just didn’t want to deal with the fallout from that.  I figured the children would lose their precious little minds if they didn’t have their trusty companions to suck on any time they were sleepy, or cranky, or sick, or even just too wound-up.

But after noticing Jonas’s teeth a few days ago, I decided I needed to step up to the Parenting Plate and put the kibosh on this once and for all.  I warned the Hyphenated Husband and his mother that it was going to get hairy around here for awhile because…

The Bink Fairy Was Coming. Duhnt-Duhnt-Duhhhhhhhnnn.

I told Jonas for two straight days that the Bink Fairy was on her way to take all the Binks to the babies who needed them, and she’d be leaving him an awesome present in return.  He asked the Bink Fairy to leave him a “Robot Dinosaur”.  Then, before heading to Grandma’s house for the night, he and Julesy helped me gather alllllll the Binks from around the house and put them in a bag for the Fairy.

Then Jonas ran around in circles yelling “I’m so excited!!!  The Bink Fairy is coming!!!

The Hyphenated Husband and I spent our date night in Toys ‘R’ Us looking for the perfect “Robot Dinosaur” for our excited little boy.  To my surprise – they had exactly what he asked for.  I wasn’t sure they made such a thing, but there it was – a stomping, roaring Robot Dinosaur.  Boy, would he be thrilled.


It was harder to pick something for Julesy because he’s at an age where his interests are constantly evolving, so we figured some indestructible board books would work for him. The next day, we brought the kids home where they discovered that the Bink Fairy had, in fact, brought them each a gift.  Jonas was so thrilled he could hardly talk.  So far the Robot Dino has not left his sight.  He even sleeps with him.

HOWEVER – The real test would come at night.  I never dreamed I could get the kids to sleep without a the little silicone suckers in the house, but much to my surprise, the boys went to bed without incident.  They each asked about the Bink once or twice, but I reminded them of the presents they got and that was enough to quiet them down.

We almost hit a road bump when Jules-The-Squirrel managed to find one stray Bink hiding wherever-it-is he stuffs things when we’re not looking.  But we got it away from him before he popped it into this mouth, and managed to divert his attention before a real meltdown occurred.

Then, Julesy even napped today without a Bink.  This is monumental. Unbelievable.  I never thought I’d see the day.

So, I think I’ve proven that we probably could have ditched the Bink long ago.  Mama and Daddy were just too lazy, and a little too comfortable with the way things were.  But I know now I’ve gotta start giving my kids more credit, because when I do, they always pleasantly surprise me.

And maybe, just maybe, we won’t bring any Binks into the house when the next baby comes along…

______________________________________________________

Did your baby(ies) use a Bink? If so, how’d you put an end to that? At what age?

Related Posts with Thumbnails


Earth Mama Angel Baby


Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

my oldest was addicted. finally I stopped buying new ones when he lost his. whenever I found a lost one I threw it in the trash. once he found a lost one and popped it in his mouth but I took it away and threw it away. it wasn't such a big deal, I really thought it would be though!

I tried to get my daughter to take a dummy. Oh, how I tried. I was convinced that it would help her with sleeping. But all she did was chew on it a bit and then look up at me like 'what's the freaking point of that?!'

But I have a similar situation in her attachment to the bottle. She still has one at night before her bath. I have a feeling I'm more attached to it because it helps to calm her down for periods of time. But as soon as this bout of 2-year-molar teething is over I think it's time for it to go.
.-= Zoey @ Good Goog´s last blog ..Guest Post @ The Feminist Breeder – Skipping Chapters =-.

My oldest never took a pacifier, she sucked her thumb instead. Now, at age 7, she still sucks her thumb.

My second daughter took a pacifier. She loved that thing. She stopped using it when she was around 2.

My son also never took one, and at 18 months, he still uses me as a pacifier.

We'll see about the newest baby when she is born. I don't plan to offer her a pacifier, but we'll see how that goes.

All of my kids have been exclusively breastfed until at least 6 months.

I started to respond and then decided I needed my own post to vent my feelings. :) I am at the point of weaning my almost 2 year old twins from the binky....

http://rustedsun.blogspot.com/2010/04/binky-sus-du...
.-= Rusted Sun´s last blog ..binky, sus, dummy, the plug, sucky-do, baby mute button =-.

A couple of my girls used them and then for kids 4 and 5 I just never got any. They were born at home so there was no "gift bag"or nursery staff. I did not buy any. We just went on like they did not exist. I was really surprised the first time because I thought it would be difficult but it wasn't. Maybe we were lucky in some way because I suppose it could have gone totally different.

I've never used a paci with my boys but I LOVE your idea of a binky fairy!!
.-= Sarah @ OneStarryNight´s last blog ..HonestScrap, BeautifulBlogger, & 24 Random Facts =-.

For once, my child is SLEEPING and I get to COMMENT. I'd almost forgotten what it felt like to do that..=P

Anyway, no binks in our house. I'd love to say that it was a parenting choice that I really strongly believed in, yadda yadda, but really? Someone told me that I *had* to buy binks and that I would *never* survive the first month without one.

Yeah. Go ahead. Tell me that I CANNOT do something and I guarantee that I will.

So the lesson here is that I am really just a stubborn ass.
.-= Sarah @ BecomingSarah.com´s last blog ..There she goes! =-.

Do babies NEED pacifiers?? I irrationally can't stand them (even though I've found them helpful with other people's kids) and they do seem like they are unnecessary... but then I read about babies' natural reflex to suck and am not sure how I feel. We definitely don't plan to use one for the first month or more as I intend to exclusively breastfeed and I'm hoping I can get away without ever buying one. They are cute for baby dolls but seeing a toddler with one grosses me out to be honest.

Side note: LOVE that dinosaur toy! What kid wouldn't pass up a Bink for that!
.-= Janine´s last blog ..Khloe Kardashian Floral Jumper & Look for Less =-.

Ahhh, the addictive pacifier! My three older children loved their pacifiers. In our house, we called it the wah-wah. They slept with it, played with it, rode in the car with it. We had wah-wahs in the bed, toy box, on the kitchen counter, in the car. We had wah-wahs up the wah-zoo! lol
I must admit, I began to depend on the wah-wah to keep my children quiet and happy. It pretty much took over our lives and somewhere around the time my daughter Maya was 3 years old (Yes! Three!) we finally decided to pitch the dang blasted thing. It was tough, but we did it and let me tell you...I was so relieved to find that my new baby hates pacifiers!
Congratulations on getting rid of the Bink and thank you so much for stopping by and commenting on my breastfeeding post. I really appreciate it. Have a great day!

Kristi, Live and Love...Out Loud@TweetingMama

.-= Kristi {at} Live and Love...Out Loud´s last blog ..Twelve Steps to Twelve Months of Breastfeeding Success =-.

NICU was "nice" enough to send my son home with one...that we couldn't get rid of. When his sister was born we refused to give her one...and she started sucking her thumb. When my son tossed his last binky in the toilet, and I refused to buy an almost 2 yo a new one, he started sucking his thumb.
I am digging the Bink Fairy idea...
.-= Heather (qtberryhead)´s last blog ..Divorce Bill Of Rights =-.

congrats! We did very much the same thing with the paci fairy when ours were 4 and 2. It was much easier than expected, and I notice my older child comes for hugs more often for comfort when before she would run for her pacifier. Like you I think we should have done it earlier, four is a bit old for a pacifier!

They were a lifesaver when the kids were infants though, mine never had any nipple confusion, I waited until nursing was going well before using the paci, so I think they do have their place. Just have to bite the bullet and get rid of them before the kid is in Kindergarten!
.-= geekymummy´s last blog ..the joy of skiing =-.

hah, we could never get the wonder twins to take pacifiers! we still have one floating around and they pop it in, pop it out and give it sardonic looks. they nursed for 20 months.

My oldest was given a binky in the hospital nursery because, as the kind nurse put it, it was the only way to get her to shut up. The binky then became her best friend and she would scream if you took it. After a month of that, I took it from her, she screamed for a day then forgot about it.

We didn't want to give our new baby a binky because we were worried she would be dependent on it. However, like you, if she didn't have her binky, my boobs would NEVER get a break. She just liked to suck and only recently mastered getting her thumb to her mouth. She's 10 weeks and we still let her have it only because she's not really a slave to it. It's convenient when we are out shopping or I'm in the middle of cooking dinner and she wants the boob.
.-= Jen´s last blog ..Ten Weeks =-.

My first used one for only about 2-3 months when she was a baby. She was done with it around 5 months I think. Rare, I think. The second didn't use one at all. But I was at home with them with my boob stuffed in their faces all day. If I had been working like you I'm sure my story would be different.
.-= Melodie´s last blog ..Do Breastfeeding Posts With Pictures Require Warnings? =-.

My first was given a soother (soucie, in our house - a bastardized version of the French verb soucer, "to suck") at three weeks by me, because I was exhausted after holding my pinkie finger in his mouth all night long for him to suck. He was ATTACHED after that, with no problems whatsoever for our lengthy and positive breastfeeding experience. He gave it up at about 26 months, when we were down to the last one in the house, and his baby brother did not have one. We were renovating a house then, and for my boy, a trip to the dump was a HUGE deal. We talked about how lucky soucie would be to go the dump in a real garbage truck (also another huge attraction). He threw it into the garbage himself, after I cut the tip off of it on the sly and proclaimed it broken. He checked on it a couple of times that day, but never complained or asked for it again. He did wave goodbye very happily to the garbage truck on garbage day, yelling through the window for soucie to have fun at the dump! LOL!

My second baby never had a soucie, but my third baby did. We threw it away at 30 months, same time as the sippy cups, when she kept throwing them down the stairs in the evening for attention (we were in a temporary home, in another country). I again cut the tip off of the soother, brought it back up, and cried that she had broken it, and now it was gone, and there were no soucies in the country we were in. And that was it. She asked for it for a couple of nights, but no tears, and no tantrums, and lots of sleep. :)

My son was given a pacifier in the hospital, but never really liked it. He preferred to nurse.
Then around 2 months his reflux was in full force and he took the paci (the sucking can help with the reflux). He rarely used it though and it was mostly for nights/naps. Then around 6 months he got his first cold and ear infection and he was done with the paci. We threw them out and never looked back.
I was then his pacifier until 2 days ago. My son would nurse ALL day if I let him. Around a month ago, I was done with it and I could tell he was too. I never thought I would see the day he went to sleep/took a nap without nursing. But one night he did and we never looked back. He turned 19 months on Sunday and officially weaned yesterday. He did have some formula very early, but quickly rejected the bottle around 6 weeks. He went to daycare full time at 6 months and would eat food, never take a bottle. So technically my son was almost exclusively breastfed for 19 months. I feel very proud of that fact, despite the side-eye I got from a lot of people. :)

I've always considered pacifiers to be unnecessary and - I'm going to be brutally honest about my opinion here - detrimental to a child's development. They may have their place with a tube-fed preemie, a bottle-fed under 6 month old or for car journeys etc... But a normal, breastfed baby IMO is born the way nature intended; all sucking reserved for breasts. By using a bink you're just creating an unnecessary habit. If mama's present and has boobs, then a pacifier shouldn't be used. Also, one should never be used "alone", meaning if there's a pacifier in baby's mouth, baby should be in somebody's arms.

Teaching a child to suckle constantly and to derive comfort from a little plastic thing sounds scary to me. I also got a few as presents but never saw a need to use them - I have boobs :) Some people have used them to calm a child down if there's been nursing issues (over-active letdown I hear is something that can cause babies to rebell at the breast, mine just gobbled it all up no matter how hard I sprayed :D)

As you can see, I'm a little against using pacifiers :) I don't see why an average baby would need one. My thoughts are basically: If one is needed, then it should be treated as a breast - always attached to an adult. Never leave baby alone with a pacifier, that's teaching them to rely on things instead of people. Plus creating an addiction that has nothing to do with our natural need to suckle.

We did the Binky Fairy too! He was 3yrs old. It worked like a charm. =)

With my first born, he wouldn't take a nuk, only our finger. We'd spend countless hours of the day with our finger in his mouth. It was absolutely draining so around 3 weeks old, we started getting him to take one instead of our finger. He never used it alllll day long and when he was 16 months old he got his first bad cold and couldn't use it. We just gathered them all up and got rid of them. He didn't ask for one after that at all. Easy.

My second daughter was extremely attached to hers. She had one in her mouth OR my boob. We had a plan to bring the fairy to our house and were reminding her ever so often about it. After all, she was nearly 3 years old. Then one day, we lost ALL her nuks. They all just disappeared. We just simply told her that we couldn't find any and she was totally cool with it. I am glad because we just came clean about Santa, the Easter Bunny and all those fakies so telling her about a pacifier fairy just didn't sit well with me!

My third baby hasn't ever had one besides the few times she found one and chewed on the wrong side.
.-= Vicki ´s last undefined ..Response cached until Wed 21 @ 15:00 GMT (Refreshes in 23.88 Hours) =-.

The week before Max turned 2 we went to the store and let him pick out a video. Since TV was a new thing for him at that point, we told him that he could watch his new movie, only after he threw away his "plug". He used a pacifier only at nap time and bed time then, so it took about 3 nights of him carrying his pacifier over to the garbage can, looking at the sealed movie, then popping the pacifier in his mouth and ignoring the movie before he finally tossed the pacifier in the garbage. He asked for it a couple times over the next few nights, but went to bed without a fuss when we reminded him that he tossed it out.

When my son was a babe he got a little bit into the pacifier, but we introduced it late and used it only when he needed the non-nutritive sucking (the kid needed to suck to poo when he was 3/4mos) and when we were in the car. He never really became attached and as he got older, would occasionally find one, pop it into his mouth and in a few minutes he'd be done.

My daughter has refused outright. She is almost 5 months old now and never took too it, she won't be fooled by any "dumb-tit"....she doesn't take a bottle either (which causes the little bit of time away I get to be guilt and phone call/text-ridden. *sigh* )

So that habit is easily conquered here, Ralegh was introduced to it sometime around 6-8 weeks, with Stella it was later. So the later the better, until it's too late!

The bink fairy is brilliant! My sister in law bid good-bye to her daughter's bink by tossing it out the car window one day...oops...

Good luck! That's intense that the two of them are letting go of their addiction together!

I've gotten our 2.5 yr old to exclusively use binky at night but not all together. His binky has been a huge constant throughout his life as he has been sick so much and the only positive oral experience he had for a long time. He even had a special one cut down to use while intubated. Right now we're working hard on oral feeding so once we finally get that steady we might think about the binky. Or we might wait and work on potty first. I'm afraid of that day that binky goes away!

My first I when he was born had decided he didn't like binkies. Then at around 6mo I kind of forced it upon him in his sleep, lmao, because the kid WOULD NOT stay asleep unless my boob was in his mouth. Mainly my fault since he was such a gentle nurser, I'd go right back to sleep at night when he nursed.

Then after he was a year, and he had words then regressed, his speech therapist suggested we get rid of the binkies. Since they were "plugging" him up. I'll admit, it wasn't just a naptime, bedtime thing. It was all day whenever he wanted it kind of thing.
So we got rid of them. Fast. He didn't start using words again until after 18 months.

At that same time, my middle son was "sort of" using them. He didn't have the same love for them as his brother did. So it wasn't a big of a deal for him.

Little girl hates them. Despises them. At night when she's wanting to comfort nurse all night, I try to give her the soothie from the hospital. But she tastes it and makes a disgusted look. I guess I shouldn't blame her. But I can't really *allow* her to comfort nurse. I have a pretty strong let down and she'll vomit up what she's eaten.
I don't plan on doing anything for my letdown though. It's nice knowing I have plenty of milk, and block nursing makes me engorged.
.-= mommymichael´s last blog ..sacrifices =-.

Wow, glad it went so well. I'm usually of the mind that kids should be allowed to give these things up on their own, but if it went this smoothly I'd say they were ready. (Those dinos are great, we have a big red T-Rex!) My first had a soo-soo, mainly used in the car and sometimes at sleeptime and naptime at daycare. It didn't impact breastfeeding because with all the troubles we started out with, we were careful not to introduce one until things were in a groove, around 6 weeks. And he was very vocal when soo-soo was not enough :) We were very fortunate that he gave it up all on his own around 18 months (and continued to nurse for another year). I really had no plans to introduce one with #2, but he hated everything for the first 4 months, esp. the car. So I did try to get him to take one to make long drives bearable. Alas, it never worked (and we moved him to the rear-facing convertible seat, which he liked much better than the infant bucket!), which is a good thing in the long run I suppose. Never took a bottle of ebm either, though really, I think I only tried once. At 2.5 he still nurses twice a day. Probably I'll let him give it up on his own :)

We are on the cusp of fighting this good fight too. Toddler will not give it up, we almost had it completely gone (we were only using it for nap times and bed) until Benjamin was born. Then he just went back to his old baby bink ways.

It is going to be hysterics next month when we take the binks from both kids. We decided once Ben is a year old they are all gone!
.-= Danielle´s last blog ..Working on my Journey into Childbirth Education =-.

Well she only took a binky for a few months. Then she gave it up on her own and I was all proud...until she started sucking her thumb. So now we have a thumb sucker and when she gets her 2 year molars in and done I will be trying (who knows how???) To curb that.

I bought a couple of pacifiers when my daughter (my first) was born "just in case". I could never really get her to take one, and I was glad, because I didn't really like the way they covered up half her face. Yeah, it meant she comfort-nursed more, right up until we night weaned her at 2.5 (and I felt the same after the night-weaning - I put it off because I thought it would mean hysterics, and as it turns out, it was practically a non-issue).

Based on this, we didn't get any when my son was born, and we've made it through 9 weeks without one, so hopefully that means we won't need it. I just make sure my boob is very available...

I remember reading in The Baby Whisperer (one of the only things that I remember from that book) is that the british call soothers "dummies" - because they 'dummy the baby up'. It can definitely morph into that if you're not careful...

My son was a binky addict from the get go. The child would suck on anything, anytime, anywhere so it didn't hinder breastfeeding or anything for us, but NOW... at almost three, he's still a binky addict. Except we call it "night night". Why? Because it USED to just be for night time. When my daughter came along and he decided to stop nursing "night night" became "all the time" - except we still call it night night. UGH. We've tried cold turkey, just for naps and bed (which is mostly where we're at now...) and hopefully soon, the binky fairy will come. The present idea is a good one! Fortunately, my 11 month old never really took the binky at all. This also means she never took anything else, except boob. All. The. Time. Which is great, but also, tiring for me. But, I'm glad that at least with her, I won't have a binky battle. If we have a third, I'll go binky free, because giving it up is wrecking me!!! LOL

Like Azucar, we didn't even buy binkies at first. We were gifted a couple so I let me son try one. He completely rejected it and was content to just nurse and to some degree comfort himself at my breast. He didn't even suck his thumb! My daughter liked the binky, but when our pediatrician said that using one was already re-shaping her mouth (this was at 3 months), I took it away and she went cold turkey. She fussed at bedtime for a couple of nights, but got to sleep without it and we never looked back.
.-= Fran´s last blog ..Retinopathy In Premature Babies: Vision Problems Can Last a Lifetime If Not Caught Early =-.

My daughter is 22 months and still uses a paci for naps and night time ever since she first started stealing them out of other babies' mouths at daycare. I really had no intention of her evr having one, and scoffed at my friend who told me I might need them when she took me to register for baby stuff. I'm no exactly sure when or how we'll be able to wean her from them. I'm guessing she'll understand the paci fairy more in a few months. I really hope it works. Congrats on your success.

We didn't use a pacifier with our first baby at all. I think we had two from a pack that someone had given us? I was even gifted a really nice pacifier chain that still sits unused inn a drawer somewhere.

When baby two came along, we still had the original pacifiers. He was needier than our first, so from the age of 3 months to 5 months my husband would give the babe one when he was hysterical and I was driving the mad ten minute dash home from work to nurse him. A 15-20 minute suck twice a week for two months didn't create an addict, but he would have definitely been one had I given in to it.

I know I'm in the minority, but I really hate pacifiers. Can't stand them. It's irrational, I KNOW.
.-= Azucar´s last blog ..Dah-ling, I Love You, But Give Me Park Avenue =-.

My daughter had a twisty journey with the pacifier. She was given one pretty much at birth in the NICU, and I relied on it heavily for her first few months of life. However, she was also nipple confused and we had a real struggle with breastfeeding. The only way I could get her to nurse for the first few months was using a nipple shield. When I finally ditched the nipple shield I ditched the pacifier, because I wanted to make sure to avoid any further confusion.

But when my daughter was 1 and I went back to work I bought her some pacifiers. I thought using one might help her nap, since she generally nursed to sleep at home. However, she was monumentally uninterested. Until she was 19 or 20 months old, and she found an old pacifier at the back of a drawer. By then she knew that all the other kids at daycare had them and she wanted one. Except she didn't suck it, she sort of chewed on it and took it out to nurse if she needed actual comforting.

After 24 hours of watching her chew on the pacifier, and then cry when she dropped it, I took it away. Honestly, I didn't want her to get hooked on it as a toddler and have to deal with a difficult removal process. Plus, she wasn't even really deriving comfort from it, that I could tell. So they went away, she was sad for 20 minutes, and we never looked back.
.-= Amber´s last blog ..Cultivating Cleaning Enthusiasm =-.